Difference between revisions of "User talk:JLaTondre"
ErickSoares3 (talk | contribs) (→The Epic of Gilgamesh: new section) |
|||
Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
Way back in [[ISFDB:Community_Portal/Archive/Archive49#The_Epic_of_Gilgamesh|2020]] you wanted to fix how The Epic of Gilgamesh is presented in the database, and I'd like to return to this discussion, because I think that is extremely wrong to present this work as a "Novel". I have sent to Anniemod how I would like [[User_talk:Anniemod#The_Epic_of_Gilgamesh|to change it]]: what do you think? Thanks, [[User:ErickSoares3|ErickSoares3]] ([[User talk:ErickSoares3|talk]]) 06:11, 4 March 2023 (EST) | Way back in [[ISFDB:Community_Portal/Archive/Archive49#The_Epic_of_Gilgamesh|2020]] you wanted to fix how The Epic of Gilgamesh is presented in the database, and I'd like to return to this discussion, because I think that is extremely wrong to present this work as a "Novel". I have sent to Anniemod how I would like [[User_talk:Anniemod#The_Epic_of_Gilgamesh|to change it]]: what do you think? Thanks, [[User:ErickSoares3|ErickSoares3]] ([[User talk:ErickSoares3|talk]]) 06:11, 4 March 2023 (EST) | ||
+ | :I have not read the book so I do not have opinion on that change. Thanks. -- [[User:JLaTondre|JLaTondre]] ([[User talk:JLaTondre#top|talk]]) 08:09, 4 March 2023 (EST) |
Revision as of 09:09, 4 March 2023
Archives
2008 ∙ 2009 ∙ 2010 ∙ 2011 ∙ 2012 ∙ 2013 ∙ 2014 ∙ 2015 ∙ 2016 ∙ 2017 ∙ 2018 ∙ 2019 ∙ 2020 ∙ 2021 ∙ 2022
Contacting Aliens: An Illustrated Guide to David Brin's Uplift Universe
I'm reaching out to the primary verifiers of the title because I believe it should be re-categorized from "Nonfiction" to "Collection" and I need to gain a consensus. You're marked as a verifier of the 2002 trade paperback edition of Contacting Aliens: An Illustrated Guide to David Brin's Uplift Universe. I think that "Collection" is a better descriptor for the work as it is written in the style of an in-universe guidebook and the contents are all short, encyclopedic entries about fictional alien species and cultures. (Side note, I'm not sure if I am setting up a new topic on your page correctly - my apologies if I've done so incorrectly.) Leporidae (talk) 12:11, 13 February 2023 (EST)Leporidae
- My verification was a transient verification (meaning I only had the book temporary). I don't recall enough about it to weigh in - I'm fine either way. Nonfiction vs fiction for "in universe" writing is a borderline case where valid arguments can usually be made either way. I don't have a strong opinion on it. Though, if you are going to change it to collection, the individual contents should be entered. And yes, you created a new section correctly. The "Add topic" button at the top of the screen will work on any talk page. Thanks. -- JLaTondre (talk) 17:13, 13 February 2023 (EST)
The Epic of Gilgamesh
Hello JLaTondre!
Way back in 2020 you wanted to fix how The Epic of Gilgamesh is presented in the database, and I'd like to return to this discussion, because I think that is extremely wrong to present this work as a "Novel". I have sent to Anniemod how I would like to change it: what do you think? Thanks, ErickSoares3 (talk) 06:11, 4 March 2023 (EST)