EditBug:10065 Variant Titles

• EditBug:10065 Variant Titles OPEN There's something I don't understand happening with this display. I did the following:

• New Novel: Test Title 1 by Test Author 1
• New Novel: Test Title 2 by Test Author 2
• Make Pseudonym: Test Author 2 is a pseudonym of Test Author 1
• New Novel: Test Title 1 by Test Author 2
• Make Variant: TT1 by TA2 is a vt of TT1 by TA1

Unless I'm missing something, that should have caused the Test Author 1 biblio to show two version of Test Title 1; one by Test Author 1 and one under the pseudonym of Test Author 2. I'll leave these records out there in case they're needed; let me know if I can delete them. Mike Christie (talk) 10:47, 23 Dec 2006 (CST)

After each step:

• New Novel: Test Title 1 by Test Author 1

 Author1:
   Test Title 1

• New Novel: Test Title 2 by Test Author 2

 Author1:                         Author2:
   Test Title 1                     Test Title 2

• Make Pseudonym: Test Author 2 is a pseudonym of Test Author 1

 Author1:                         Author2:
   Test Title 1                   Alternate Name Used By: Author1
                                    Test Title 2

• New Novel: Test Title 1 by Test Author 2

 Author1:                         Author2:
   Test Title 1                   Alternate Name Used By: Author1
                                    Test Title 2
                                    Test Title 1

• Make Variant: TT1 by TA2 is a vt of TT1 by TA1

 Author1:                         Author2:
   Test Title 1 (as by Author2)   Alternate Name Used By: Author1
                                    Test Title 2

Which is as intended. Are you saying you want to see:

 Author1:                         Author2:
   Test Title 1                   Alternate Name Used By: Author1
      Variant: Test Title 1         Test Title 2
      (as by Author2)

Alvonruff 07:00, 9 Jan 2007 (CST)

The current display seems to match my current understanding of ISFDB. Test Author 1 shows

• Test Title 1 (2006) [as by Test Author 2 ]

And it does show both the version of Test Title 1; one by Test Author 1 and one under the pseudonym of Test Author 2. Test Author 2 shows

• Test Title 2 (2006)

I personally would like it if Test Author 2’s bibliography also showed the variant title so that you could look at a pseudonym bibliography and see all of the works written under that pseudonym but believe that's unrelated to what you reported.

I also posted a question to Al about this as I’m still uncertain as to just what the step “Make Pseudonym: Test Author 2 is a pseudonym of Test Author 1” does to the database but think it’s buried in the queue User_talk:Alvonruff#Help_for_the_pseudonym_editor. Marc Kupper 18:36, 10 Jan 2007 (CST)

Here are two titles from Aldiss's bibliography:

• Non-Stop (1958)

• Variant Title: Starship (1985)
• Variant Title: Starship (1960) [as by Brian Aldiss ]

• The Primal Urge (1961) [as by Brian Aldiss ]

For "Non-Stop", Aldiss published the first edition as by "Brian W. Aldiss", and then some subsequent reprints in three forms:

1. as "Non-Stop" by Brian W. Aldiss
2. as "Starship" by Brian W. Aldiss
3. as "Starship" by Brian Aldiss

Perhaps because the vts are a different title here as well as a different name, the biblio says "Nonstop (1958)" and does not say "[as by Brian Aldiss]".

For "Primal Urge", on the other hand, the first edition (and the only independent publication recorded in the db to date) was as by "Brian Aldiss". It makes sense for this to show "[as by Brian Aldiss]".

What is good about the Aldiss presentation of the two vts of "Non-Stop" is that I can tell from this that "Starship" was published both as by BWA and by BA. That's the information that is lost in the Test Author display, because it does not use the vt display with as separate line for each title/author combination.

Hence I think what I'm asking for is that a title section in a biblio should not imply (via the "as by") that a book was only published under that variant name. (Ideally it could also report differently depending on which name was used for first, or canonical publication, but I realize that isn't possible as we don't identify first editions directly.) How about if the biblio were to say "also as by" if the biblio's author name is found (along with the pseudonym) in the pub list for the title? For "Primal Urge", no change is necessary since we don't record a version of it as by "Brian W. Aldiss". For the first line "Non-Stop", no change would be necessary as there was no version of "Non-Stop" by "Brian Aldiss" under the original title. However, the second line could then be:

• Variant Title: Starship (1960) [also as by Brian Aldiss]

For the original display question, it would read

   Author1:
     Test Title 1 (also as by Author2)

These are actually two changes; the change to vt display may not be even desirable since it doesn't add new info, and loses the separate date info that is there now. The change to main (non-vt) title display would add info, though.

This is probably a feature request, not a bug. Al, do you agree? Do you think this is desirable, and well enough defined for me to move over to the feature list? Mike Christie (talk) 05:10, 13 Jan 2007 (CST)