ISFDB banner

Canceled/Rejected Publication Update Submission

You are not logged in. If you create a free account and sign in, you will be able to customize what is displayed.

Cancellation/Rejection Reason: this is record for first printing

Note: For "Edit" submissions, the "Current" column shows the data as it currently exists in the database, not as it existed when the submission was created.

Column Current Record #[333106] Proposed Changes Warnings
Title The National Review Treasury of Classic Children's Literature -  
Transliterated Title - -  
Authors William F. Buckley, Jr. -  
Date 2002-12-00 2003-03-00  
Publisher ISI Books -  
Pub Series - -  
Pub Series # - -  
Pages 508 -  
Format hc -  
Pub Type ANTHOLOGY -  
ISBN 096278415X -  
Catalog ID - -  
Price $29.95 -  
Image Coverart
[https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51YGTVVM93L.jpg]
Coverart
[https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/726153-L.jpg]
 
Web Page - -  
Note
  • Data from Internet Archive scan of second printing
  • "1st ed" as part of LoC data
  • "First printing in December 2002" per second printing
  • Cover has "Selected by William F. Buckley, Jr.". Title page has no credit.
  • "Jacket Design by Luba Myts" on copyright page
  • Most stories are illustrated with multiple artworks. These are currently entered as a single entry.
  • "Sir Marrok" artwork is signed, but name cannot be made out in scan
  • "Bruno's Revenge" artwork is signed, but name cannot be made out in scan.
  • Also contains the following non-genre stories: page 88, "In Yeddo Bay" by Jack London page 95, "To Repel Boarders" by Jack London page 220, "Baby Sylvester" by Jack Bret Harte page 249, "Tom Sawyer Abroad" by Mark Twain page 336, "A Race with an Avalanche" by Fanny Hyde Merrill page 340, "In a Ring of Fire" by F. H. Kellogg page 423, "Danny and the 'Major'" by Gertrude P. Greble page 477, "Jack Dilloway's Scheme" by Jefferson Lee Harbour
  • It is not clear all the remaining stories are genre. Verifier should check.
  • LCCN per copyright page
"Second printing in March 2003" on copyright page of Archive.org copy.

-<ul>
-<li>Data from Internet Archive scan of second printing
-<li>"1st ed" as part of LoC data
-<li>"First printing in December 2002" per second printing
-<li>Cover has "Selected by William F. Buckley, Jr.". Title page has no credit.
-<li>"Jacket Design by Luba Myts" on copyright page
-<li>Most stories are illustrated with multiple artworks. These are currently entered as a single entry.
-<li>"Sir Marrok" artwork is signed, but name cannot be made out in scan
-<li>"Bruno’s Revenge" artwork is signed, but name cannot be made out in scan.
-<li>Also contains the following non-genre stories:
-page 88, "In Yeddo Bay" by Jack London
-page 95, "To Repel Boarders" by Jack London
-page 220, "Baby Sylvester" by Jack Bret Harte
-page 249, "Tom Sawyer Abroad" by Mark Twain
-page 336, "A Race with an Avalanche" by Fanny Hyde Merrill
-page 340, "In a Ring of Fire" by F. H. Kellogg
-page 423, "Danny and the ’Major’" by Gertrude P. Greble
-page 477, "Jack Dilloway’s Scheme" by Jefferson Lee Harbour
-<li>It is not clear all the remaining stories are genre. Verifier should check.
-<li>LCCN per copyright page
-</ul>
+"Second printing in March 2003" on copyright page of Archive.org copy.
External IDs LCCN: 2003101756
OCLC/WorldCat: 56722009
OCLC/WorldCat: 56722009
Open Library: OL8520634M
 

Modified Regular Titles

Current Proposed Warnings
Title The National Review Treasury of Classic Children's Literature -  
Authors William F. Buckley, Jr. -  
Date 2002-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type ANTHOLOGY -  
Length - -  
Page - -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title Introduction (The National Review Treasury of Classic Children's Literature) -  
Authors William F. Buckley, Jr. -  
Date 2002-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type ESSAY -  
Length - -  
Page xiii -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title Casperl -  
Authors Henry Culyer Bunner -  
Date 2002-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type SHORTFICTION -  
Length short story -  
Page 81 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title Between Sea and Sky -  
Authors Hjalmar H. Boyesen -  
Date 2002-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type SHORTFICTION -  
Length short story -  
Page 124 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title The Happychaps [2] -  
Authors Carolyn Wells -  
Date 1908-07-00 2002-12-00  
Type POEM -  
Length - -  
Page 185 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title The Three Fortunes -  
Authors Howard Pyle -  
Date 1888-07-24 2002-12-00  
Type SHORTFICTION -  
Length short story -  
Page 204 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title Tiger! Tiger! -  
Authors Rudyard Kipling -  
Date 2002-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type SHORTFICTION -  
Length short story -  
Page 388 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title The Happychaps [3] -  
Authors Carolyn Wells -  
Date 1908-12-00 2002-12-00  
Type POEM -  
Length - -  
Page 402 -  
Current Proposed Warnings
Title Tommy and the Meadow Mice -  
Authors Thornton W. Burgess -  
Date 1914-11-00 2002-12-00  
Type SHORTFICTION -  
Length short story -  
Page 441 -  

Secondary Verifications

Source Status Verifier Date
OCLC/Worldcat Verified Rtrace 2010-10-15 21:56:10

View the submission as raw XML

Submitted by Username on 2022-04-09 16:00:40

Rejected by JLaTondre on 2022-04-10 09:21:49

Copyright © 1995-2022 Al von Ruff and the ISFDB team
ISFDB Engine - Version 4.00 (2006-04-24)